Research

* Ph.D. student co-author · ** master's or undergraduate student co-author

Journal articles

Does Privacy Regulation Harm Content Providers? A Longitudinal Analysis of the Impact of the GDPR

Vincent Lefrere*, Logan Warberg*, Cristobal Cheyre, Veronica Marotta, Alessandro Acquisti

Management Science · 72(3): 1727–1747 · 2026

This paper investigates the real-world impact of the GDPR on online content providers. Contrary to widespread industry fears, our findings show that while EU websites adapted by reducing user tracking, the regulation did not significantly harm their ability to produce content, engage audiences, or survive in the market.

Presented at FTC PrivacyCon (2019, 2022) and the FTC Bureau of Economics (2022)

Abstract

Concerns that the European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) would adversely affect the ability of news and media websites to create new quality content have not been thoroughly investigated in the literature. We construct a longitudinal data set of European Union (EU) and U.S. news and media websites to study how online content providers responded to the GDPR over time and whether potential restrictions on online tracking enforced by the regulation affected their downstream outcomes. We find robust evidence that both EU and U.S. news and media websites responded to the regulation by altering their data collection practices, but did so differently, with EU websites reducing tracking and implementing consent mechanisms at higher rates than their U.S. counterparts. Although we detect a reduction in average page views per user on EU relative to U.S. websites, we do not find evidence of negative impacts, in both the short and long term, on EU websites’ provision of new content or on several proxies for quality of that content, such as social media engagement metrics, various traffic measures, and articles’ text analytics. We also find no evidence of differences in survival rates across EU and U.S. news and media websites, and no evidence that monetization strategies changed at higher rates on EU relative to U.S. websites. The analysis suggests that EU online content providers did implement changes to their data collection practices in response to the GDPR but were able to use data minimization and consent mechanism strategies that allowed them to keep producing content and engage audiences at degrees on par with their U.S. counterparts.

Published version Preprint Video

Economic Rationales for Regulating Behavioral Ads

Pegah Moradi*, Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

Yale Journal of Law & Technology · 28: 336 · 2026

This paper evaluates the economic arguments surrounding privacy regulation in behaviorally targeted advertising. While industry groups often claim that regulation harms innovation and consumer welfare, our review of theoretical and empirical evidence shows that these claims are weakly supported. We demonstrate that privacy regulation can be economically justified—not only ethically or legally—by reducing harms and promoting a fairer distribution of value in the digital economy.

Abstract

Advocates for regulating behaviorally targeted advertisements tend to focus on ethical and legal justifications for regulation. Meanwhile, the advertising technology industry has staunchly opposed regulation by drawing on economic arguments, contending that such regulation would be harmful to advertisers, consumers, publishers, and data intermediaries alike—ultimately undermining innovation and accessibility of free products across the Internet. In this Article, we analyze the theoretical and empirical economic literature on the costs and benefits of privacy regulation in the context of behavioral advertising in order to evaluate the strength of economic arguments for and against regulation. Our analysis suggests that recent enforcement actions against ad-technology firms and movements across the world for online privacy regulations may be justifiable not merely on ethical or moral grounds, but on economic grounds. We show that current economic arguments used by the ad industry to oppose privacy regulation are poorly substantiated, and therefore do not outweigh valid legal and ethical justifications for privacy regulation. Furthermore, there are valid theoretical and empirical economic justifications for regulating behavioral ads. Rather than resulting in a loss of welfare for consumers, regulation may produce a reduction of harms and a more balanced allocation of the costs and benefits of data accumulation. Still, future economic work must move from analyzing narrow micro-level effects to research designs that are both rigorous and encompassing, allowing for a fuller understanding of impacts across stakeholders to more effectively inform privacy regulation.

PDF Preprint Video

Eyes, Locks, Patterns, Tiers: How Intelligent Crime-Control Technology Amplifies Demands for Frontline Retail Workers

Pegah Moradi*, Karen Levy, Cristobal Cheyre

ILR Review Forthcoming

This study examines how emerging loss-prevention technologies reshape frontline retail work. Drawing on industry materials and interviews and observations of retail workers, we identify four approaches—eyes, locks, patterns, and tiers—and show that intelligent crime-control systems can intensify managerial monitoring and increase workers’ relational demands rather than simply replacing labor.

Abstract

Retailers are increasingly adopting loss-prevention technologies to counter rising concerns over theft. While systems are primarily aimed at customers, millions of frontline retail workers remain central to their implementation. This article examines how emerging crime-control technologies reshape frontline retail work. First, drawing on retail-technology marketing materials and observations at industry conferences, we identify four approaches promoted by vendors: eyes (behavior observation), locks (physical access restriction), patterns (automated anomaly detection), and tiers (customer access differentiation). Eyes and locks reflect long-standing retail security practices, and patterns and tiers introduce “intelligent” layers atop them. Second, through interviews and observations of frontline workers across the United States, we show that these intelligent layers shift workers’ relationships within the worker-manager-customer triad by (1) intensifying monitoring and managerial control over workers, and (2) creating more relational demands. We argue that studying behavior-control technologies targeted at customers enables a better understanding of qualitative changes in frontline jobs.

A Park for All: Layering Transgenerational, Translocal, and Parochial Experiences of Immigrant Communities in Los Angeles

Rosie Nguyen*, Lee Humphreys, Maria Goula, Cristobal Cheyre, Duarte Santo, Jose Antonio Guridi Bustos*, Marco Rangel

Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies · 1–24 · 2026

This study examines how public parks can foster inclusion and belonging among immigrants in Los Angeles—the nation's most park-poor yet one of its most diverse cities. Through a participatory project to transform a former landfill into a public park, we explore how immigrants' transgenerational and translocal experiences shape their perceptions and use of green spaces. The findings highlight design practices that make public spaces more inclusive of diversity and difference.

Abstract

This study examines how public parks can foster inclusion and belonging among immigrants in Los Angeles—the nation’s most park-poor yet one of its most diverse cities. Through a participatory project to transform a former landfill into a public park, we explore how immigrants’ transgenerational and translocal experiences shape their perceptions and use of green spaces. The findings highlight design practices that make public spaces more inclusive of diversity and difference, offering insights into how urban environments can better support immigrant communities.

Published version

Image Generative AI to Design Public Spaces: A Reflection of How AI Could Improve Co-Design of Public Parks

Jose A. Guridi*, Cristobal Cheyre, Maria Goula, Duarte Santo, Lee Humphreys, Achilleas Souras**, Aishwarya Shankar**

Digital Government: Research and Practice · 6(1): Article 7, 1–14 · 2025

This study explores how image-generative AI could change the way policymakers engage the public in designing public spaces. In a case study of the redesign of a former landfill into a public park in Los Angeles, we generated images from immigrants' interview insights and reflected on the process, identifying opportunities for richer engagement, risks such as encoded biases and power imbalances, and features that would support safe and responsible use.

Abstract

Image generative AI (IGAI) could change how policymakers engage with the public to design public spaces, facilitating how designers translate the public’s desires into features. However, using IGAI has challenges, such as encoded biases, which might reinforce stereotypes and harm underrepresented communities. We conducted a case study to explore how using IGAI alters the co-design process of public parks through public engagement. We use data collected from interviews with immigrants discussing the Puente Hills Landfill Park design in Los Angeles, which will re-purpose a former landfill into a new public park. We use Dream Studio as a Design Probe, generating images from the interviewees’ insights and critically reflecting on the design process through internal interviews and a reflective workshop. We analyze our case in three domains: Opportunities, Risks and Challenges, and Features and Requirements. In the opportunities domain, we discuss how the enhanced translation of words to images changes the relationship between stakeholder engagement, multiplicity, and efficiency. In the risks and challenges domain, we discuss how IGAI might enhance power imbalances and biases. Finally, we reflect on what features would ease the safe and responsible use of IGAI to engage citizens in co-designing public parks.

Published version

Spinoffs and the Ascension of Silicon Valley

Cristobal Cheyre, Jon Kowalski, Francisco M. Veloso

Industrial and Corporate Change · 24(4): 837–858 · 2015

This article traces how the semiconductor industry came to cluster in Silicon Valley after the introduction of the integrated circuit. Studying entry and performance from 1965 to 1987, we find that Silicon Valley entrants were more likely to enter at the technological frontier, and that long-run top producers were disproportionately spinoffs of leading firms or diversifiers with a transistor background. Once heritage is accounted for, location itself does not predict success.

Abstract

This article analyzes firm entry and performance in the semiconductor industry from the introduction of the integrated circuit (IC) in 1965 until 1987. During this period the industry, which was initially concentrated on the east coast of the United States, became increasingly clustered in Silicon Valley (SV), California. This location shift was accompanied by a change in the technology used to produce semiconductor devices. By studying how diversifiers and new firms enter into IC production, and the technology they choose to produce ICs, we document the process of growth of SV. In particular, we analyze how agglomeration economies, as well as the heritage of new firms’ founders affect the opportunities pursued by entrants and their long-term likelihood of success. We find that IC entrants in SV were more likely to enter at the technological frontier than IC entrants in other clusters. However, we find no evidence suggesting that being located in a cluster helped existing IC producers that were not initially at the technological frontier to catch up with the rest of the industry. Examining long-term performance, we find that firms that become top producers are disproportionately spinoffs of leading firms or diversifiers with a transistor background. While most of these firms were located in SV, after controlling for heritage and background, location has no significance on the likelihood of becoming a top producer.

Published version

Spinoffs and the Mobility of U.S. Merchant Semiconductor Inventors

Cristobal Cheyre, Steven Klepper, Francisco Veloso

Management Science · 61(3): 487–506 · 2015

Using patent data, this paper studies why semiconductor inventors were more mobile in Silicon Valley. We show that much of this mobility is explained by the entry of spinoffs—even before the industry clustered there, and independent of the ban on noncompete agreements—so the benefits of greater mobility accrue disproportionately to new firms.

Abstract

Data on inventors and assignees of patents are used to analyze the mobility of semiconductor inventors. Exploiting data on the origins of semiconductor producers with larger sales, we argue that the higher mobility of semiconductor inventors in Silicon Valley is in great part due to the entry of spinoffs there. Our empirical evidence suggests that spinoff entry promoted mobility in Silicon Valley even before the industry was clustered there. Agglomeration economies and the ban on noncompete covenants may influence spinoff entry, but spinoffs promote mobility even in the absence of those conditions. Because most of the greater inventor mobility in Silicon Valley corresponds to inventors moving from incumbents to recent entrants, the benefits that arise from greater mobility rates will be disproportionately reaped by new firms.

Published version

Under review & in revision

Did Apple's App Tracking Transparency Framework Harm the App Ecosystem?

Cristobal Cheyre, Benjamin Leyden, Sagar Baviskar*, Alessandro Acquisti

Management Science · CESifo Working Paper No. 10456 Under review (third round)

This study examines how Apple’s App Tracking Transparency (ATT) framework affected the App Store ecosystem. Using data on every app in both the Apple App Store and Google Play Store over an 18-month period, we analyze how developers and consumers adapted to stricter privacy rules. Despite industry concerns that ATT would harm app innovation and revenue, we find no evidence of widespread developer exit. Instead, developers adjusted by reducing reliance on advertising SDKs and modestly increasing use of authentication and payment tools, with minimal impact on consumer ratings or engagement. The results suggest that privacy regulation can prompt adaptation rather than disruption in digital ecosystems.

Abstract

We study the impact of Apple's App Tracking Transparency (ATT) framework on the Apple App Store ecosystem. ATT restricted developers' access to personal identifiers used for targeted advertising. Promoted as a privacy-enhancing initiative, the change drew sharp criticism from advertising technology firms, who predicted that it would substantially harm the app ecosystem. We collect data on every app available on both the Apple App Store and the Google Play Store in the 18 months around the implementation of ATT. We use a difference-in-differences analysis to comprehensively investigate whether the introduction of ATT negatively affected the app ecosystem. We analyze multiple possible downstream effects including developers’ engagement with the ecosystem—measured through entry, exit, app updates, and adoption of Software Development Kits (SDKs)—and on consumers’ valuation of apps, proxied by the volume and average rating of reviews. We find that the number of available apps on the Apple App Store quickly rebounded after an initial drop, driven by a temporary decline in entry rather than an increase in exit. In terms of use of Software Development Kits (SDKs), developers slightly reduced their reliance on Monetization and Ad Mediation SDKs and modestly increased their use of Authentication and Payment SDKs. These adjustments did not meaningfully affect consumer valuations of apps. Existing apps experienced a small decline in ratings received, while new entrants received slightly more ratings in their first month. Overall, our results suggest that, contrary to pessimistic predictions, ATT did not trigger developer withdrawal but instead prompted adaptation to a more privacy-protective regime.

Preprint

Do #BlackLivesMatter on Kickstarter? Assessing the Impact of Kickstarter's Support of Black Creators

Anthonia Carter*, Cristobal Cheyre

Marketing Science (Frontiers) Minor revision

Following George Floyd’s murder in 2020, many companies—including Kickstarter—publicly expressed support for racial justice. This study examines whether Kickstarter’s visible #BlackLivesMatter campaign, displayed across the platform for over a year, led to improved outcomes for Black creators. Using data on projects launched before and after the campaign, we find that while the initiative increased the participation of Black creators, it did not raise their funding success rates. The findings highlight the limits of symbolic corporate activism and the persistent structural inequities faced by underrepresented creators in digital platforms.

Abstract

In the wake of George Floyd's murder in 2020, many corporations displayed the #BlackLivesMatter hashtag in support of racial justice. While such expressions of solidarity may raise awareness and act as catalysts for reducing racial injustices, it remains unclear whether they lead to meaningful improvements for the communities they aim to support. This study investigates whether Kickstarter's support for #Black-LivesMatter led to an improvement in the outcomes Black creators experience on the platform. In May 2020, Kickstarter changed the color of its logo to black and added the #BlackLivesMatter (#BLM) hashtag under it. This change was visible on every page of the platform for over a year. We analyze if this intervention led to better outcomes for Black-led projects by analyzing projects on Kickstarter from May 2019 to June 2021. Our findings indicate that while the initiative successfully increased Black creators' participation on the platform, it did not lead to higher funding rates for Black-led projects. This may lead to disappointment as Black creators attracted to the platform by the intervention continue to experience low levels of support in line with historic disparate outcomes.

Preprint

Online Intermediation in Legacy Industries: Evidence from the Adoption of Restaurant Reservation Platforms

Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

Information Systems Research Major revision

Using data on over 6,000 New York City restaurants, this study shows how platforms like OpenTable reshape pricing and competition in traditional industries. Restaurants typically pass platform fees on to consumers, while moderate adopters benefit most from participation. The findings reveal both the value and the risks of relying on digital intermediaries.

Abstract

Digital platforms have become increasingly prevalent across a wide range of traditionally offline industries, reshaping business-to-consumer interactions through online intermediation. While these platforms reduce search and transaction costs and are broadly popular among consumers, their growing role has raised concerns among businesses that resent platform fees, as well as among regulators who worry about the concentration of power in a small number of gatekeepers. In this paper, we explore the impact of such platforms on prices and firm survival in legacy industries. We use the case of OpenTable—a leading online restaurant reservation platform—to examine how the rise of an online intermediary has affected both incumbent firms and consumers in the restaurant sector. We compile a rich panel dataset of more than 6,000 restaurants in New York City between 2005 and 2016, combining information on prices, platform participation, and business survival. Using a variety of empirical approaches, we find that restaurants adopting OpenTable tend to raise their prices by an amount roughly equivalent to the platform’s per-diner fee. We observe more nuanced effects on survival: for most restaurants, OpenTable adoption does not significantly affect exit rates. However, restaurants that attract only a moderate share of customers through the platform are less likely to exit—and notably, this group does not raise prices after adoption. These findings suggest that while online intermediation can create value for both buyers and sellers, overreliance on intermediary platforms may increase costs for firms and contribute to higher prices. The results have important managerial and policy implications. Legacy businesses should seek to benefit from platform participation without losing their lower-cost, direct customer channels. Regulators, meanwhile, should encourage innovation in digital markets while guarding against conditions that incentivize overuse of online intermediaries.

Preprint Video

Intentional AI Adoption: Deciding Where AI Belongs Before the Market Decides for You

Jose Guridi*, Cristobal Cheyre, Duarte Santo, Lee Humphreys, Maria Goula

California Management Review Under review

This article examines how professional firms should decide where AI belongs before adoption is driven by individual experimentation or market pressure. Based on interviews with 25 practitioners and participant observation in landscape architecture, we develop an Intentional AI Adoption framework that maps tasks by identity and accountability stakes, protects work that builds professional judgment, and makes experimentation visible to the firm.

Abstract

This article examines how professional firms should decide where AI belongs before adoption is driven by individual experimentation or market pressure. Based on interviews with 25 practitioners and participant observation in landscape architecture, we develop an Intentional AI Adoption framework that maps tasks by identity and accountability stakes, protects work that builds professional judgment, and makes experimentation visible to the firm.

Paradoxical Strategies for Emerging Technology Governance

Jose Guridi*, Julio Pertuze, Clara Caffrey, Cristobal Cheyre

Research Policy Under review

This study examines how governments steer emerging technologies when goals, impacts, and evaluative criteria remain unsettled. Drawing on interviews with 28 senior AI policymakers across 22 countries, we identify eight structural tensions and show that effective governance depends less on resolving them than on using paradoxical strategies to keep competing demands in productive balance over time.

Abstract

Governing emerging technologies poses a distinctive challenge for innovation policy: how to provide direction amid deep uncertainty, where technological trajectories, societal impacts, and evaluative criteria remain unsettled. Artificial intelligence (AI) exemplifies this condition, as governments seek to steer its development toward societal goals amid rapidly evolving capabilities and contested policy objectives. Existing policymaking frameworks, which emphasize the coherence, consistency, credibility, and comprehensiveness of the policy mix, implicitly assume that these attributes can be jointly maximized—an assumption that strains under conditions of emergence. Drawing on Paradox Theory and interviews with 28 senior AI policymakers from 22 countries, this article conceptualizes emerging technologies governance as a system of enduring and interdependent tensions. We identify eight structural tensions that systematically shape the elements and processes of the policy mix. Rather than resolving these tensions, effective policymakers adopt paradoxical strategies that sustain competing demands in productive balance over time. The article advances innovation policy in three ways. First, it introduces Paradox Theory as a foundational theoretical logic for analyzing policy mixes under deep uncertainty. Second, it reconceptualizes directionality as the capacity to navigate persistent contradictions rather than to achieve static alignment. Third, it reframes the role of governments in transformative innovation policy as active managers of paradoxes, offering a theoretically grounded alternative to coherence-centered models of policy design.

Preprint

Archival conference proceedings

Pseudo-Automation: How Labor-Offsetting Technologies Reconfigure Roles and Relationships in Frontline Retail Work

Pegah Moradi*, Karen Levy, Cristobal Cheyre

Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction (CSCW) · 9(2): CSCW153 · 2025

This paper examines how self-checkout machines—often framed as automation—actually shift labor onto customers while transforming the work of cashiers. Drawing on interviews with frontline retail workers, we show that self-checkout introduces new forms of multitasking, problem-solving, and customer policing, often positioning workers in adversarial roles. To manage these tensions, cashiers perform “relational patchwork,” using empathy and improvisation to preserve positive customer interactions. The study reveals how pseudo-automation reshapes not only tasks but also relationships in service work.

Abstract

Self-service machines are a form of pseudo-automation; rather than actually automate tasks, they offset them to unpaid customers. Typically implemented for customer convenience and to reduce labor costs, self-service is often criticized for worsening customer service and increasing loss and theft for retailers. Though millions of frontline service workers continue to interact with these technologies on a day-to-day basis, little is known about how these machines change the nature of frontline labor. Through interviews with current and former cashiers who work with self-checkout technologies, we investigate how technology that offsets labor from an employee to a customer can reconfigure frontline work. We find three changes to cashiering tasks as a result of self-checkout: (1) Working at self-checkout involved parallel demands from multiple customers, (2) self-checkout work was more problem-oriented (including monitoring and policing customers), and (3) traditional checkout began to become more demanding as easier transactions were filtered to self-checkout. As their interactions with customers became more focused on problem solving and rule enforcement, cashiers were often positioned as adversaries to customers at self-checkout. To cope with perceived adversarialism, cashiers engaged in a form of relational patchwork, using techniques like scapegoating the self-checkout machine and providing excessive customer service in order to maintain positive customer interactions in the face of potential conflict. Our findings highlight how even under pseudo-automation, workers must engage in relational work to manage and mend negative human-to-human interactions so that machines can be properly implemented in context.

Published version Preprint

Thoughtful Adoption of NLP for Civic Participation: Understanding Differences Among Policymakers

Jose A. Guridi*, Cristobal Cheyre, Qian Yang

Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction (CSCW) · 9(2): CSCW193 · 2025

This study explores why governments have been slow to adopt natural language processing (NLP) tools for civic participation, despite their potential to enhance democratic engagement. Through interviews with politicians and public servants, we find that differing career incentives and concerns about legitimacy shape how each group evaluates and designs NLP tools. The absence of clear responsibility for advocating or overseeing adoption further hinders progress. These insights highlight the social and institutional factors that influence AI adoption in government and inform the design of NLP systems that better support public participation.

Abstract

Natural language processing (NLP) tools have the potential to boost civic participation and enhance democratic processes because they can significantly increase governments' capacity to gather and analyze citizen opinions. However, their adoption in government remains limited, and harnessing their benefits while preventing unintended consequences remains a challenge. While prior work has focused on improving NLP performance, this work examines how different internal government stakeholders influence NLP tools' thoughtful adoption. We interviewed seven politicians (politically appointed officials as heads of government institutions) and thirteen public servants (career government employees who design and administrate policy interventions), inquiring how they choose whether and how to use NLP tools to support civic participation processes. The interviews suggest that policymakers across both groups focused on their needs for career advancement and the need to showcase the legitimacy and fairness of their work when considering NLP tool adoption and use. Because these needs vary between politicians and public servants, their preferred NLP features and tool designs also differ. Interestingly, despite their differing needs and opinions, neither group clearly identifies who should advocate for NLP adoption to enhance civic participation or address the unintended consequences of a poorly considered adoption. This lack of clarity in responsibility might have caused the governments' low adoption of NLP tools. We discuss how these findings reveal new insights for future HCI research. They inform the design of NLP tools for increasing civic participation efficiency and capacity, the design of other tools and methods that ensure thoughtful adoption of AI tools in government, and the design of NLP tools for collaborative use among users with different incentives and needs.

Published version Preprint

From Fake Perfects to Conversational Imperfects: Exploring Image-Generative AI as a Boundary Object for Participatory Design of Public Spaces

Jose A. Guridi*, Angel Hsing-Chi Hwang, Duarte Santo, Maria Goula, Cristobal Cheyre, Lee Humphreys, Marco Rangel

Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction (CSCW) · 9(2): CSCW014 · 2025

This study explores how image-generative AI (IGAI) can support participatory design processes for public spaces. Through workshops and AI-mediated interviews conducted during a real-world park redesign in Los Angeles, we find that IGAI shifts the focus of design conversations—from producing accurate renderings to fostering richer, more spatially grounded discussions among stakeholders. The results highlight both the promise and the challenges of using generative AI in collaborative settings, including the crucial role of facilitators and the skills needed to manage human–AI–stakeholder interactions.

Abstract

Designing public spaces requires balancing the interests of diverse stakeholders within a constrained physical and institutional space. Designers usually approach these problems through participatory methods but struggle to incorporate diverse perspectives into design outputs. The growing capabilities of image-generative artificial intelligence (IGAI) could support participatory design. Prior work in leveraging IGAI's capabilities in design has focused on augmenting the experience and performance of individual creators. We study how IGAI could facilitate participatory processes when designing public spaces, a complex collaborative task. We conducted workshops and IGAI-mediated interviews in a real-world participatory process to upgrade a park in Los Angeles. We found (1) a shift from focusing on accuracy to fostering richer conversations as the desirable outcome of adopting IGAI in participatory design, (2) that IGAI promoted more space-aware conversations, and (3) that IGAI-mediated conversations are subject to the abilities of the facilitators in managing the interaction between themselves, the AI, and stakeholders. We contribute by discussing practical implications for using IGAI in participatory design, including success metrics, relevant skills, and asymmetries between designers and stakeholders. We finish by proposing a series of open research questions.

Published version Preprint

Trends in Privacy Dialog Design after the GDPR: The Impact of Industry and Government Actions

Logan Warberg*, Vincent Lefrere, Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

Workshop on Privacy in the Electronic Society (WPES '23) · 107–121 · 2023

Many EU websites first responded to the GDPR with privacy dialogs that offered inadequate choices or nudged visitors toward accepting tracking. Following 911 U.S. and EU news and media websites for 18 months, we find that government and industry actions were followed by more dialogs offering a clear option to accept or reject tracking, and fewer nudges toward acceptance.

Abstract

Prior research found that a significant portion of EU-based websites responded to the GDPR by implementing privacy dialogs that contained inadequate consent options or dark patterns nudging visitors towards accepting tracking. Less attention, so far, has been devoted to capturing the evolution of those privacy dialogs over time. We study the evolution of privacy dialogs for a period of 18 months after the GDPR became effective using screenshots from the homepages of 911 US and EU news and media websites. We assess the impact of government and third-party actions that provided additional guidance and tools for compliance on privacy dialogs' choice architecture. Over time, we observe an increase in the use of privacy dialogs providing the option to accept or reject tracking, and a reduction of nudges that encourage users to accept tracking. While the debate over the extent to which various stakeholders' responses to the GDPR meaningfully improved EU residents' privacy remains open, our results suggest that exogenous shocks (such as government interventions) may prompt websites to enact changes that bring on-the-ground implementation of the GDPR at least nominally closer to its intended goals (such as making rejecting tracking easier for visitors).

Published version

The Impact of Viral Posts on Visibility and Behavior of Professionals: A Longitudinal Study of Scientists on Twitter

Rakibul Hasan*, Cristobal Cheyre, Yong-Yeol Ahn, Roberto Hoyle, Apu Kapadia

International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media (ICWSM) · 16(1): 323–334 · 2022

This study examines what happens after ordinary users unexpectedly go viral. Using the tweeting activity and follower networks of 17,157 scientists on Twitter, we find that after a first viral event, scientists tweeted more often, with more focused, positive, and expertise-aligned content, and gained more followers in both the short and long term than a matched control group.

Abstract

On social media, due to complex interactions between users' attention and recommendation algorithms, the visibility of users' posts can be unpredictable and vary wildly, sometimes creating unexpected viral events for 'ordinary' users. How do such events affect users' subsequent behaviors and long-term visibility on the platform? We investigate these questions following a matching-based framework using a dataset comprised of tweeting activities and follower graph changes of 17,157 scientists on Twitter. We identified scientists who experienced 'unusual' virality for the first time in their profile lifespan ('viral' group) and quantified how viral events influence tweeting behaviors and popularity (as measured through follower statistics). After virality, the viral group increased tweeting frequency, their tweets became more objective and focused on fewer topics, and expressed more positive sentiment relative to their pre-virality tweets. Also, their post-virality tweets were more aligned with their professional expertise and similar to the viral tweet compared to past tweets. Finally, the viral group gained more followers in both the short and long terms compared to a control group.

Published version

Working papers

The Effects of Online Advertising on Consumer Purchase Behavior, Outcomes, and Satisfaction: A Registered Report

Cristobal Cheyre, Li Jiang, Florian Schaub, Zijun Ding*, Cristiana Firullo*, Yucheng Li*, Alessandro Acquisti

This registered report studies how online advertising, behavioral targeting, and privacy technologies affect consumers’ purchasing behavior and satisfaction. Using a three-month field experiment that randomly assigns 1,200 U.S. participants to targeted ads, anti-tracking, or ad-blocking, we separate the effects of advertising itself from behavioral targeting across consumers’ real-world browsing and purchases.

Abstract

The online advertising ecosystem’s reliance on consumer behavioral tracking creates an intense, unresolved debate over the impact of online ads on consumer shopping behavior, outcomes, and satisfaction. Existing empirical work has been helpful, but identifying the causal effects of ad exposure separately from behavioral targeting across the advertising ecosystem, and the potential impact of privacy technologies on that ecosystem, presents methodological challenges. This Registered Report presents a large-scale, ecosystem-wide, randomized, three-condition longitudinal field experiment. Participants are assigned to (1) Targeted Ads, (2) Anti-tracking, or (3) Ad-blocking conditions, and both observational and survey data are collected over a three month period. This design estimates the incremental effect of targeting and allows for a causal test of three competing macro-theories that predate the digital age: the Informative Engine (Nelson 1974), the Market-Shuffling and User Experience Engine (Dixit and Norman 1978), and the Complementary View/Peripheral Influence Engine (Hansen and Christensen 2003). This field experiment provides an ecosystem-wide assessment of the causal impact of online advertising on consumer purchasing behavior, outcomes, and satisfaction.

Beyond Search: LLM Adoption and Web Traffic Concentration

Samira Gholami*, Cristiana Firullo*, Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

Do large language models replace web search and pull traffic away from websites? Using comScore browsing data from 2022 to 2024 and the staggered timing of users' LLM adoption, we find that adoption is followed by a sustained increase in the number of unique websites users visit. Whereas search engines funnel traffic toward a narrow set of destinations, LLMs spread users across a wider range of websites.

★ WISE 2025 Best Student Paper Award

Advertising, Personalization and Search Costs: Evidence from an Online Field Experiment

Cristiana Firullo*, Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

Does online advertising help consumers find what they are looking for, or distract them? In an online field experiment that randomly assigns participants to different advertising conditions, we test whether personalized ads lower consumers' search costs—helping them reach their goals in fewer steps and less time—beyond the effect of ad exposure alone.

Consent and Choice: Experimental Evidence on User Behavior at Consent Banners

Cristiana Firullo*, Francesco Decarolis, Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

CEPR Discussion Paper No. 22078, 2026

How do people respond to cookie consent banners? Using a browser extension that varies how easy it is to accept, reject, or customize cookies, we observe consent decisions during participants' everyday browsing. Many users close banners without making any choice, which makes website defaults critical, and our estimates suggest consumer surplus is highest when banners present choices clearly.

The Welfare Effects of Ad-Blocking

Fengyang Lin*, Cristobal Cheyre, Alessandro Acquisti

NET Institute Working Paper No. 23-05

This field experiment studies how much users value ad-blockers and how being exposed to or shielded from online advertising affects their experiences. Removing an ad-blocker worsened users' online experiences and satisfaction with recent purchases, while installing one reduced purchase regret and improved well-being. Valuations vary widely: some users refuse even large payments to switch, but most will switch for moderate amounts.

Abstract

Concerns regarding online tracking and excessive advertising have led to a marked increase in the adoption of Ad-Blocking tools. We conduct a field experiment to study users’ valuation of Ad-Blockers, and to study how exposing or shielding users from online advertising influences their online experiences, their attitudes towards online advertising, their valuation of ad-blocking tools, and their future usage of such tools. We find that for users currently using an ad-blocker, uninstalling them leads to a deterioration in their online experiences and lower satisfaction with recent purchases. For users that were not using Ad-Blockers, installing one led to fewer reported regrets with purchases, an improvement in subjective well-being, and a less positive view of online advertising. In terms of users’ valuation of Ad-Blockers, we observe a great degree of heterogeneity. Some users are not willing to uninstall their Ad-Blocker even if offered large payments (>$100). Conversely, a similar number of users are not willing to install an Ad-Blocker even if offered large payments. However, most users are willing to install/uninstall an Ad-Blocker in exchange for moderate payments (<$20). Our experimental treatment has a large effect on future usage of Ad-Blockers. Participants that we ask to install an Ad-Blocker are much more likely to use Ad-Blocker after the experiment ends than comparable participants in the control group. However, not all this effect can be attributed to the benefits of Ad-Blocking, as we also observed that the participants that we asked to uninstall their Ad-Blocker are more likely to continue not-using an Ad-Blocker after the experiment ends, although the magnitude of this effect was smaller.

Preprint

How Race and Gender Stereotypes Impact Crowdfunding Outcomes

Anthonia Carter*, Atishay Jain, Hoda Heidari, Cristobal Cheyre

Do crowdfunding backers evaluate founders differently by race and gender? In an experiment, participants rate projects aimed at Black women while we vary the founder's race and gender. Backers see White male founders as less prepared to lead such projects, yet this does not significantly reduce their willingness to fund them; Black female founders, in contrast, face greater scrutiny of their fit with the product and market.

Research infrastructure

The Internet Behavior Experiment (IBE) is a longitudinal field-experimental infrastructure that combines cross-environment observation with randomized interventions. Custom study software, installed by consenting participants on their computers and mobile devices, records browsing, search queries and responses, advertising exposure, online purchases, and interactions with generative AI tools within a privacy-aware environment, and lets us deploy randomized interventions within participants' everyday digital environments.

The Internet Behavior Experiment (IBE): An Experimental Infrastructure for Ecologically Valid Studies of Online Advertising, Tracking, and Targeting

Cristobal Cheyre, Li Jiang, Florian Schaub, Zijun Ding*, Cristiana Firullo*, Yucheng Li*, Alessandro Acquisti

NET Institute Working Paper No. 24-10

Abstract

The manuscript presents a novel experimental methodology for studying the impact of online advertising, tracking, and targeting on consumer behavior. Existing approaches rely heavily on observational data, which suffer from self-selection and limited causal identification, or platform-specific experiments, which provide strong internal validity but cannot capture the broader consumer journey across the web. Laboratory and survey studies, while controlled, lack ecological validity and temporal depth. The methodology resented here addresses those limitations by deploying a client-server infrastructure that enables randomized interventions in advertising exposure, tracking, and argeting, while collecting rich, longitudinal data across multiple platforms and devices. The methodology integrates multiple captured behaviors (including browsing, advertising exposure, shopping and search, purchase confirmation, promotional emails) with periodic self-report surveys. Rigorous privacy and security safeguards ensure responsible handling of sensitive data. The manuscript illustrates the capabilities of the methodology with a demonstration experiment that assigns participants to full behavioral advertising exposure, ad-blocking, or anti-tracking conditions over three months, allowing tracing the effects of interventions on product search patterns, purchases, and satisfaction. Beyond consumer welfare, the methodology can support a wide range of inquiries into media consumption, vendor diversity, exposure to political or health-related advertising, interactions with large language models, and more.

Preprint

Research funding

Additional support from the Cornell Center for Social Sciences, the Cornell Center for Data Science for Enterprise & Society, the George Mason University Program on Economics and Privacy, the NYU NET Institute, the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center, the University of Pennsylvania (Economics of Digital Services Initiative, Center for Technology, Innovation & Competition, and Warren Center for Network & Data Sciences), and Carnegie Mellon University (CyLab, the Block Center for Technology and Society, and university seed funding).